Members banned from this thread: Iolo
The state legislature in South Carolina has fast tracked a bill that will ban the ACA in the state. It is expected to be signed before the first of the year. According to lawyers the way this is written it will be legal. Thoughts?
"This provision, according to Davis, comes from the anti-commandeering doctrine established in case law that says feds can’t compel states to enforce federal laws.
What the Supreme Court said in Printz v. United States is that states are not merely political subdivisions of the federal government to carry out what the federal government does; they are sovereign entities,” Davis said. “Congress can pass laws, but it cannot compel the states to utilize either their treasury or personnel to implement those federal laws.
Additional provisions of H3101 further neuter the Affordable Care Act by outlawing state exchanges, issuing tax deductions to individuals equal to the tax penalties levied by the federal government, and directing the state attorney general to sue over whimsical enforcement of the law. Taken together, the provisions effectively repeal the federal law for the people of South Carolina."
South Carolina voting on bill to end Obamacare in state | The Daily Caller
| || |
Upsettion I believe you are a lawyer, do you think this will hold?
The only thing that would pass muster would be a law which said, "The State of South Carolina will have nothing to do with it"
THAT they can refrain from doing, but nullifying Federal law? No...
"The proposed legislation gives the Attorney General of South Carolina powers to prevent agencies and employees of the state from aiding any agency or employee that enforces or attempts to enforce the PPACA. This bill empowers the Attorney General to sue such businesses or employees whenever he has reasonable grounds to believe those businesses or employees are causing harm to people or businesses by assisting in the implementation of Obamacare. The Attorney General can also apply for an injunction to stop such implementation."
If signed I wonder if it will need to be taken up again by higher courts.
"They probably will try to secede. Idiots!"
"I hope they secede. Idiots!"