Results 1 to 5 of 5
Thanks Tree7Thanks
  • 1 Post By The Man
  • 3 Post By Rasselas
  • 1 Post By Dr.Knuckles
  • 2 Post By Ian Jeffrey

Thread: Press Freedom vs. Fake News

  1. #1
    The Un-Holy One The Man's Avatar
    Joined
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    38,559
    Thanks
    23545

    From
    Toronto

    Press Freedom vs. Fake News

    France's media regulator has issued a warning to RT France, the French outlet of Russia's state-run broadcaster, over its presentation of facts and claims made in a program about a chemical-weapons attack in Syria.

    The Conseil Superieur de l'Audiovisuel (CSA) said in a statement late on June 28 that an April 13 RT program about an alleged attack in the Syrian region of Eastern Ghouta, among other things, dubbed over the voices of Syrian civilians with words they had not said.

    France's warning highlights the dilemma facing Western governments in dealing with Russian state-run media, which often trumpet a Kremlin view of world events that directly contradicts the view of Western world leaders.

    Right after the April 7 attack in the Syrian town of Douma, medics and rescuers said 40 people had died from exposure to chlorine and sarin gas, and Western powers blamed the incident on Syrian forces.

    The attack provoked global outrage and within days triggered retaliatory missile strikes against alleged chemical-weapons sites in Syria by the United States, Britain, and France.

    But in a news feature headlined Simulated Attacks, the French regulator said RT correspondents, like the Russian and Syrian governments, questioned whether the attack actually occurred and accused a local rebel group of staging a fake attack on the population.

    Russia and Syria right after the attack accused rebels and the White Helmets rescue group, which they claim sympathizes with Syria's opposition, of simulating the attack.

    More recently, Moscow has suggested that rebels launched a real chemical attack in Douma, claiming that Russian and Syrian troops since taking control over Douma have found a rebel "chemical laboratory" with equipment manufactured in "Western Europe."

    The world's chemical-weapons watchdog group, the Organization for the Prevention of Chemical Weapons, currently is investigating the Douma incident and is expected to report its findings soon.

    The French regulator said RT's program on the controversial and sensitive topic of chemical-weapons use in Syria, which has divided Russia and the West for years, displayed "failures of honesty, rigor of information, and diversity of points of view."

    "There was a marked imbalance in the analysis, which, on a topic as sensitive as this, did not lay out the different points of view," the regulator said.

    The regulator did not impose sanctions on RT, but it has the authority to fine a broadcaster or suspend its license.

    In a statement, RT France acknowledged a mistake in the French translation of comments from a Syrian witness but said this was a purely technical error which had been corrected.

    "RT France covers all subjects, including the Syrian conflict, in a totally balanced manner, by giving all sides a chance to comment," said RT France President Xenia Fedorova.

    French President Emmanuel Macron has been aggressive in seeking to curb alleged Russian media disinformation.

    The United States, by contrast, has required RT to register as a "foreign agent" with the U.S. government but -- reflecting the strong protections for press freedom in the U.S. Constitution -- has not sought to regulate aspects of its broadcasts.

    Macron has described RT, formerly called Russia Today, as a tool for "influence-peddling." He accused the broadcaster of spreading "propaganda" during his 2016 presidential campaign and banned it from his campaign headquarters.

    During a joint news conference with Russian President Vladimir Putin in Versailles last year, Macron said the broadcaster and Russian press agency Sputnik had on several occasions spread fake news and deceitful propaganda.

    Before the launch of RT France late last year, CSA chief Olivier Schrameck said that the agency would be watching the channel constantly and would respond promptly to what he called "anomalies."

    RT has also faced multiple warnings from Britain's media regulator Ofcom over its reports on Syria as well as on the conflict between government forces and Russia-backed separatists in eastern Ukraine.

    Draft French legislation might go even further to combat what the government considers "fake news," including giving the state new powers to take foreign broadcasters off the air if they attempt to "destabilize" the country.

    The measure has been viewed as aimed at RT in particular.
    France Warns Russia's RT Over Claims In Broadcast On Syrian Chemical Attack

    It is an interesting question, for Western democracies. Does restricting foreign propaganda from hostile powers amount to unlawful, undemocratic, unconstitutional censorship?
    Thanks from Friday13

  2. #2
    Veteran Member
    Joined
    Feb 2010
    Posts
    65,500
    Thanks
    37051

    From
    in my head
    Quote Originally Posted by The Man View Post
    France Warns Russia's RT Over Claims In Broadcast On Syrian Chemical Attack

    It is an interesting question, for Western democracies. Does restricting foreign propaganda from hostile powers amount to unlawful, undemocratic, unconstitutional censorship?
    They should register as agents of a foreign power. It's reasonable to at least label all such messages to identify their source.

    In the US, money is speech (or so our SCOTUS tells us), and we restrict foreign money attempting to influence our elections. If money = speech, doesn't speech = money, and thus it should be similarly restricted? I'd love to see some foreign power sue for the right to propagandize American citizens. That would be an interesting argument.
    Thanks from Ian Jeffrey, Friday13 and The Man

  3. #3
    Veteran Member Dr.Knuckles's Avatar
    Joined
    Jun 2006
    Posts
    100,505
    Thanks
    8350

    From
    Vancouver
    I know several people who read a steady stream of tabloid political pablum and get all riled up about the most ridiculous nonsense they got off a Facebook chart or blatantly fake accusations against a race or politician or group.

    But I do not know ANY of them under 40.

    Fake news isnt just a news problem. It’s also a senility problem.
    Thanks from The Man

  4. #4
    Spock of Vulcan Ian Jeffrey's Avatar
    Joined
    Mar 2013
    Posts
    64,598
    Thanks
    32734

    From
    Vulcan
    Quote Originally Posted by Dr.Knuckles View Post
    I know several people who read a steady stream of tabloid political pablum and get all riled up about the most ridiculous nonsense they got off a Facebook chart or blatantly fake accusations against a race or politician or group.

    But I do not know ANY of them under 40.

    Fake news isnt just a news problem. It’s also a senility problem.
    That's not the problem. People in that age group remember the days when news was generally trustworthy, instead of having to disbelieve most of what they read.
    Thanks from The Man and Dr.Knuckles

  5. #5
    The Un-Holy One The Man's Avatar
    Joined
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    38,559
    Thanks
    23545

    From
    Toronto
    Quote Originally Posted by Rasselas View Post
    They should register as agents of a foreign power. It's reasonable to at least label all such messages to identify their source.

    In the US, money is speech (or so our SCOTUS tells us), and we restrict foreign money attempting to influence our elections. If money = speech, doesn't speech = money, and thus it should be similarly restricted? I'd love to see some foreign power sue for the right to propagandize American citizens. That would be an interesting argument.
    Yep... Do we extend freedom of speech to propaganda from a state that itself crushes such freedom at home? If we don't shut them up, they can poison our people's minds with fake news. And if we do, we essentially become like them, so they kinda win anyway...

    Hell of a dilemma. It would be fascinating to observe a lawsuit like you suggest, yes...

    Quote Originally Posted by Dr.Knuckles View Post
    I know several people who read a steady stream of tabloid political pablum and get all riled up about the most ridiculous nonsense they got off a Facebook chart or blatantly fake accusations against a race or politician or group.

    But I do not know ANY of them under 40.

    Fake news isnt just a news problem. Itís also a senility problem.
    I hope that's true here in the West, at least...

    Because, sadly, Russia, for one, has tons of young people in groups such as Youth Guard, etc, completely brainwashed to support Putin in all he does



    Though, of course, fortunately, there are other young people, MOSTLY young people, in fact, backing Navalny and other Opposition people

    So, there's hope for the future there yet...

Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 339
    Last Post: 14th May 2018, 07:08 AM
  2. Replies: 9
    Last Post: 26th January 2018, 09:19 AM
  3. Replies: 0
    Last Post: 23rd December 2017, 03:05 PM
  4. BREITBART 'FAKE NEWS' gets front row seat at press conference...
    By cpicturetaker12 in forum Current Events
    Replies: 50
    Last Post: 12th January 2017, 09:20 PM
  5. Replies: 45
    Last Post: 7th December 2016, 06:40 AM

Tags for this Thread


Facebook Twitter RSS Feed